NEWS
Micheál Martin Blocked a Negotiated State Apology to Vindicated Former Justice Minister Alan Shatter from Being Delivered in the Dáil in 2023, Newly Revealed Draft Wording Shows
A draft state apology to former Justice Minister Alan Shatter, negotiated with the Attorney General and intended for delivery in the Dáil in 2023, was never issued after Micheál Martin blocked it, according to Shatter and newly disclosed wording of the statement.
The proposed text, prepared while Leo Varadkar was Taoiseach, acknowledged the impact of the 2014 Guerin report on Shatter and his family. It noted that ministers are sometimes compelled to leave office for reasons that, with the benefit of hindsight, do not withstand scrutiny, and stated that in light of the findings of the O’Higgins Commission and the decision of the Supreme Court, this may have been one of those occasions. Shatter has said the wording was agreed through discussions with Attorney General Rossa Fanning, who contacted him at Varadkar’s request in early 2023 to address residual issues arising from the earlier controversy.Shatter maintains that Martin, then a senior figure in the Fine Gael-Fianna Fáil coalition, opposed delivery of the apology, treating the matter as part of the ordinary rough-and-tumble of political life.
He has further claimed that other party leaders were reluctant to proceed without a clear pretext, and that he was left without a formal expression of regret despite the later findings that cleared him. Varadkar did make a Dáil statement in July 2023 recognising Shatter’s vindication, but it stopped short of the fuller apology that had been discussed.The events trace back to Shatter’s resignation as Minister for Justice in 2014. He stepped down amid intense criticism over his handling of concerns raised by Garda whistleblower Maurice McCabe, after the Guerin report concluded that he had not acted appropriately. Subsequent processes produced a markedly different picture.
The O’Higgins Commission found that allegations against him were untrue and praised aspects of his conduct. The Supreme Court later held that the Guerin process had operated as an organ of the State and that Shatter had been denied fair procedures. Other inquiries likewise failed to sustain the original criticisms. Shatter has described the intervening years as having destroyed his reputation, career and family life on the basis of findings that did not stand up.Government responses to the latest disclosures have been consistent with the position taken in 2023. A spokesman for the Taoiseach has indicated that no further apology is contemplated, noting that Shatter’s resignation was tendered for political reasons and that Varadkar’s earlier statement already acknowledged the later vindication. Correspondence from Shatter to Martin and to Tánaiste Simon Harris is said to have been received but has not produced any change in that stance.
Shatter has expressed disappointment at what he regards as an absence of decency and respect for the rule of law on the part of the political system.The episode highlights the tension between political accountability in the moment and later findings that revise the record. While the draft apology recognised that experience can show some ministerial departures do not withstand scrutiny, the decision not to proceed with it has left the formal public record without the expression of regret Shatter sought after his vindication.
