NEWS
Mayor Mamdani Calls the Man Shot by ICE a New Yorker and Demands the Agency Be Abolished — a 39-Year NYPD Veteran Says He’s an Undocumented Dominican With Trinitarios Ties
Mayor Zohran Mamdani described the man wounded by an ICE agent in Marble Hill as a New Yorker and demanded that federal immigration enforcement end in the city, including a call to abolish the agency. A retired NYPD officer pushed back, stating that the man is an undocumented Dominican national with ties to the Trinitarios gang and is not a New Yorker.
The shooting occurred around 4 p.m. on October 8, 2026, near West 225th Street and Marble Hill Avenue. NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch said surveillance footage showed plainclothes federal officers approaching a gray Honda CR-V, after which the vehicle moved forward. At least one ICE agent fired seven rounds, striking the driver below the left ear. The man, identified as 28-year-old Oscar Belgal, arrived at NewYork-Presbyterian Allen Hospital in stable condition with a non-life-threatening neck wound.
A 5-year-old boy believed to be his son was in the back seat and was not injured; police later located the child with a family member. The NYPD was not involved in the operation and had no officers on scene when the shots were fired.The Department of Homeland Security said officers were conducting a targeted enforcement action to arrest Belgal, a Dominican national in the country illegally. Officials stated he has a prior conviction for grand larceny that resulted in five years of probation, along with multiple earlier arrests for assault, robbery, drug possession, and weapons possession. DHS also said he has associations with the Trinitarios gang, the same group linked to the shooting of a Customs and Border Protection officer the previous year. Senior ICE officials said Belgal refused to exit the vehicle, accelerated, struck two ICE vehicles, and drove toward other officers before agents opened fire.
They said officers did not know a child was in the car at the time. Belgal was later transferred to a detention facility outside New York state.Mamdani posted that agents had surrounded the man and the child before firing multiple rounds and called the situation unconscionable. He said he had contacted the president to demand an end to all ICE enforcement actions in the city and wrote that he would not stand by while agents “terrorize our communities.” His post concluded with repeated calls to remove ICE from neighborhoods, hospitals, streets, and children, followed by “Abolish ICE.” He later said talks with President Trump and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin failed to secure Belgal’s release.Pete Panuccio, who identifies as a retired 39-year NYPD veteran, replied directly to the mayor’s post: “He’s an illegal, and a Trinatario gang member.
He’s not a New Yorker.” The reply, which included a short video, drew limited engagement compared with the original statement but reflected a counter-claim grounded in the immigration status and gang associations described by federal officials.The differing accounts center on both the circumstances of the stop and how Belgal is characterized. City officials have emphasized the presence of the child and the volume of gunfire in a residential area. Federal officials have emphasized Belgal’s criminal record, gang associations, and the claim that he used the vehicle against officers during an arrest attempt. Body-camera footage has not yet been released. Protests followed outside the hospital where Belgal was treated, resulting in several arrests for obstructing governmental administration.
